Steven Dell: Eye Health
Attia presents ophthalmologist Steven Dell, known for his expertise in refractive eye surgery and multiple patents. Steven explores the eye’s anatomy, functional mechanics, and common vision variations. He covers age-related vision changes, types of vision loss, and an in-depth analysis of corrective eye surgery options. He emphasizes the significance of eye protection and preventing myopia, particularly in children.
Key Takeaways
High level takeaways from the episode.
Source
We recommend using this distillation as a supplemental resource to the source material.
Full Notes
Ophthalmology and Eye Anatomy
- Ophthalmology: medical and surgical specialty dealing with the eye
- Ophthalmologists: eye surgeons who diagnose and treat eye diseases
- Optometrists: non-surgical eye care professionals who fit glasses, screen for eye diseases, and manage pre- and post-operative care
Ophthalmology Residency
- Four-year residency, including a transitional internship with exposure to various medical disciplines
- Bread and butter cases during training: cataract surgery and retinal disease treatment (often related to diabetes)
Eye Anatomy Basics
- Retina: located at the back of the eye, responsible for receiving light and converting it into electrical signals to be sent to the brain
- Cornea: clear, dome-shaped surface at the front of the eye that helps focus light entering the eye
Ophthalmology Procedures
- Cataract surgery: removal of the cloudy lens in the eye and replacement with an artificial lens
- Retinal disease treatment: various procedures to address retinal issues, often related to diabetes and its complications
Explaining the Eye - Eye is like a camera
- Front: cornea (covering, like a watch)
- Pupil: hole in the iris
- Lens: behind the pupil
- Vitreous cavity
- Retina: back of the eye, connects to the optic nerve
- Images come in, bent by cornea and lens, focus on retina
- Fovea: center of retina, where images fall
- Nearsighted: images come into focus not on retina
- Lens: size and shape of an M&M candy
- Elastic when young, less elastic and harder with age
- Cataract: lens becomes stiff, hard, and opaque
- Lens is avascular, immune privileged
- Blood-retinal barrier protects retina from systemic disease
- Potential future treatment: soften lens to delay farsightedness and cataract onset
-
Pupil: dark part of the eye, changes size due to iris movement (dilation and constriction)
Pharmacological Solutions for Presbyopia - Eye drops that shrink the pupil
- Increases depth of focus
- Works in 15 minutes
- Lasts 6–8 hours, possibly up to 10 hours
- Commercial availability expected in early 2022
- Lipoic acid choline ester
- Softens the lens
- Works in 15 months
- Aimed at reducing the incidence or delaying the onset of cataract formation
Eye Color and Evolution
- Darker eye colors offer more protection from UV and visible light
- Darker eye colors are more common closer to the equator
- Retinal pigment epithelium shields the vascular supply behind the retina from radiation
Rods and Cones
- Cones
- Responsible for daytime vision
- Clustered in the center of the retina (macula)
- Rods
- Responsible for dim illumination vision (night vision)
- Located in the periphery of the retina
- Good at detecting motion
- Both rods and cones are single cells with photosensitive structures
- Photon hits the cell, causing a change in the membrane and ion flow, generating a signal
Visual Processing in the Brain
- Most visual processing occurs in the neocortex
- Autonomic functions, like pupil responses, occur in the midbrain
- Left visual sphere sends information to the right side of the brain, and vice versa
- Optic chiasm
- Point where optic nerves cross
- If a visual deficit is in one eye only, the issue is in front of the chiasm
- If the issue affects both eyes, it is behind the chiasm
Vision and Human Performance
- Vision is the most valued sense among humans
- Most people would be least willing to give up their sense of sight
- A large part of the brain is devoted to vision
- Vision is important in various fields, such as sports
- Major League Baseball players rely on their vision to see the laces on the ball
- Some athletes undergo laser vision correction to improve their vision beyond 20/20
- The theoretical limit of human vision is defined by the pixelation of the retina
- Varies from person to person, but is around 20/08
- Achievable by removing optical irregularities and neutralizing them with glasses or laser vision correction
Contact Lenses vs. Laser Vision Correction
- Contact lenses can provide good vision, but not superhuman performance
- Body regards contact lenses as foreign objects and attacks them
- Susceptible to pollen, dust, and other debris
- Orientation of lenses for astigmatism correction can be affected by blinking
- Laser vision correction can provide better optical performance than contact lenses
- Beneficial for athletes who need the best vision possible
- Can achieve vision beyond 20/20
Vision and Evolution
- Humans have better vision than many animals, especially in low light conditions
- Possibly due to evolving as both hunters and hunted
- Humans have a poor sense of smell compared to animals
- Unclear why evolution did not push for a better sense of smell
- Vision is important for survival and functioning in the world
- Loss of vision due to trauma is a significant concern, especially for young people
- Blunt trauma is a common cause of vision loss in young people
Astigmatism and Vision
- Astigmatism: when the eye is shaped like a football instead of a basketball
- Typically occurs in the cornea (front part of the eye)
- Cornea is about 550 microns thick (half a millimeter)
- Astigmatism prevalence: around 60% of patients with glasses prescription have some degree of astigmatism
- Nearsightedness (myopia) and farsightedness (hyperopia) can be influenced by the length of the eyeball (anterior-posterior axis)
- Nearsightedness: long eyeball, difficulty seeing far away objects
- Farsightedness: short eyeball, difficulty seeing close objects
Environmental Factors in Vision Development
- Deprivation from outdoor light and near work can contribute to nearsightedness
- Studies show that children who spend more time outside have a lower risk of developing nearsightedness
- Outdoor light, especially during midday, is important for preventing myopia
- Blue light is critical for wakefulness, attention, and potentially preventing myopia
- Genetic factors may also play a role in vision development, but environmental factors seem to be more powerful
Implications for Children’s Vision
- Encouraging outdoor activities and exposure to natural light can help prevent nearsightedness in children
- Spending too much time indoors, especially in dimly lit rooms, can increase the risk of nearsightedness
- Myopia is not just an inconvenience; it can also lead to other eye-related health issues such as cataracts, myopic macular degeneration, glaucoma, and retinal tears and detachments
Children’s Outdoor Time and Vision Development - Importance of good illumination for children’s vision development
- Balance between outdoor time and indoor near activities (e.g., Legos, trains, trucks)
- Hunter-gatherer societies have well-tuned distance vision, no nearsightedness
Cataracts and Aging
- Cataracts are inevitable in aging, usually forming in the 70s
- Early signs: changes in night vision, glare, halos, streaks around lights, problems with contrast sensitivity
- Factors contributing to cataract formation: lens proteins degrading, UV light exposure, glucose in the lens, corticosteroid use, trauma
Cataract Surgery and Intraocular Lenses
- Cataract surgery involves removing the cataract and replacing it with an artificial lens
- Intraocular lenses have advanced to correct near vision, distance vision, astigmatism, nearsightedness, farsightedness, and presbyopia
- Cataract surgery is typically a once-in-a-lifetime procedure
History of Cataract Treatment
- Ancient world: “couching” procedure involved poking the lens of the eye backward, allowing unfocused light to enter
- Post-WWII: Harold Ridley discovered that plexiglass (polymethyl methacrylate) could be placed in the eye without an immune response
- Ridley’s idea led to the development of intraocular lenses, which have evolved and improved over time
Cataract Surgery and Implant Lenses - Tibial plateau made of polymethyl methacrylate, no longer used due to stiffness
- Cataract removal through tiny incisions, using ultrasound or femtosecond laser
- Implant lenses can be folded and inserted through small incisions
- Small incisions reduce healing time and astigmatism
- Implant lenses do not regrow the coating
- Can opacify after surgery, treatable with laser
- Cataract surgery can improve vision significantly
- Implant lenses can correct near and distance vision
Implant Lens Technology
- Different lenses for different patients
- More expensive lenses provide more spectacle independence
- Lenses can correct other visual defects
- Can be tuned for specific vision preferences (e.g., nearsightedness)
- Measurements needed for implant lenses
- Ensure cornea surface is pristine
- Measure length of the eye, curvature of the cornea, and index of refraction
- Calculate implant lens power and placement
Future of Implant Lenses
- Mid-2000s: development of zoom-focus implant lenses
- Lenses that could move or change shape
- Surpassed by bifocal and trifocal implants in capability
- Potential game-changer: a lens that can change shape or position and zoom focus seamlessly from near to far
- Implanting lenses from deceased individuals not feasible, unlike corneas
Corneal Pathology and Dry Eye - Corneal abrasions: common issue caused by lack of lubrication or dry eye
- Dry eye: caused by various factors
- Medications with anticholinergic side effects
- Antihistamines
- Hormonal influences (e.g., lack of testosterone)
- Autoimmune conditions (e.g., Sjogren’s, rheumatoid arthritis)
- Thyroid metabolism issues
- Treatment for dry eye
- Artificial tears (eye drops)
- Omega‑3 fatty acid supplementation
- Omega‑6 fatty acid supplementation (e.g., gamma-linolenic acid)
Light Exposure and Eye Health
- Balance between too much and too little light exposure
- Sunglasses recommended for protection against:
- Skin cancer on lower eyelid
- Photo aging of the lens (delaying cataract onset)
- Retinal damage (reducing risk of age-related macular degeneration)
- Light-eyed patients more susceptible to UV damage due to less pigment
- Wearing sunglasses when outside during daylight hours is advised for eye protection and longevity
Sunglasses and Eye Protection - Importance of wearing sunglasses even on overcast days
- Protects from damaging light
- UV filter is the key for eye health protection, not the tint
- Polarized lenses
- Blocks light in one meridian, letting all light through in another
- Helpful for reducing glare on water or highways
- No evidence that polarization is better for eye health than non-polarized lenses
Glasses vs. Contact Lenses
- Safest option is glasses (spectacles)
- No risk associated with them
- Debate between long-term contact lens wear and laser vision correction
- Laser vision correction may be recommended if contacts are inconvenient or cause infections
Laser Eye Surgery
- PRK (Photorefractive Keratectomy) came before LASIK
- FDA approved in the mid-1990s
- First procedure done in New Orleans by Dr. Margaret McDonald
- PRK and LASIK use excimer lasers
- Originally used to etch microchips
- Can make cuts in human tissue without generating heat or immune response
- PRK changes the curvature of the cornea to improve vision
- Cannot change the length of the eye, which also affects vision
- Only a small change in curvature is needed to focus light on the retina
Laser Vision Correction: PRK
- PRK (Photorefractive Keratectomy) is a type of laser vision correction
- Procedure:
- Eye is anesthetized
- Alcohol solution is applied to the cornea to remove the epithelial layer (about 50 microns thick)
- Laser is used to reshape the cornea by vaporizing tissue
- Laser moves around the cornea to avoid overheating tissue
- Procedure takes about 2–3 minutes per eye
- Recovery:
- Epithelial layer heals over in about 4 days
- Vision improves quickly, but full recovery takes several days
- A contact lens is used as a bandaid during the healing process
- PRK and LASIK have similar results 30 days after the procedure, but LASIK has a faster recovery time
Eye Tracking During Laser Vision Correction
- Patients’ eyes can move during the procedure
- Laser can track eye movement faster than the patient can move their eye
- Laser will not fire unless the eye is within its range of tracking
- Eye movement is not a significant concern during the procedure
Digital Mapping of the Eye
- Before laser vision correction, the eye is digitally mapped using a wafer sensing device
- A narrow beam of light is sent into the eye, and the distortion of the light as it bounces back is measured
- This information is used to determine the distortions in the eye and build a customized laser vision correction plan
- The technology was originally developed for telescopes to correct for atmospheric distortion
LASIK and PRK Eye Surgery - LASIK and PRK are two types of corrective eye surgery
- LASIK involves creating a flap in the cornea and reshaping it
- Faster recovery time, less postoperative care
- More common, about 80–85% of corrective eye surgeries
- PRK involves removing the epithelium and reshaping the cornea
- Slower recovery time, more postoperative care
- Better for patients with thin corneas or preexisting dry eye
- Both procedures can result in temporary dry eye
- Night vision issues have been largely resolved with advancements in technology
- Costs for both procedures are similar, averaging around $4,000 per eye in North America
- Exclusion criteria for both procedures include:
- Unstable cornea
- Irregular astigmatism
- Autoimmune diseases
- Other eye diseases (cataract, glaucoma, retinal pathology)
- Smile procedure is an alternative to LASIK and PRK
- Uses a single laser and a smaller incision
- Designed to reduce dry eye and speed up recovery time
- Not yet proven to be better or equal to LASIK or PRK
Air Puff Telemetry and Glaucoma
- Air puff telemetry not considered gold standard for measuring pressure
- Blinking quickly and squeezing can cause false readings
- Glaucoma: damage to the optic nerve related to pressure
- Many different types of glaucoma, but all share this common pathway
- Some people have normal pressures but still develop optic nerve damage
- Symptoms of glaucoma
- No symptoms until very end, when peripheral vision is damaged
- As it progresses, can affect central vision and become symptomatic
- Glaucoma treatment
- Pharmacological management has improved
- Laser procedures and minimally invasive glaucoma procedures (MIGS) available
- 80% of glaucoma cases caused by chronic open-angle glaucoma
- Problem of overproduction of fluid inside the eye, causing high pressure
- Glaucoma screening
- Annual eye exams check for glaucoma
- Incidence increases with age, more important to pay attention to in 50s and beyond
UV Exposure and Eye Health
- Natural sunlight exposure important for eye health
- Wearing sunglasses can help protect eyes from UV damage
- Hats can also provide some protection
- Nutritional supplements for eye health
- Vitamin C deficiency associated with elevated risk of cataracts
- Antioxidants (A, C, E) have no effect on cataract formation
- Lutein and zeaxanthine may have weak protective effects for cataracts and macular degeneration
Screen Use and Eye Health
- No evidence that screen use causes macular degeneration or cataracts
- Amount of UV radiation from screens is very low
- Blue light from screens can disrupt circadian rhythm
- Exposure to blue light at night can make it harder to sleep
- Blue-blocking glasses may help with this issue
Effects of Blue Light and Screen Time on Eyes
- Blue light from screens can disrupt circadian rhythms
- Not necessarily damaging to eyes, but can affect sleep
- Passive watching TV vs. active engagement with screens (e.g., checking email)
- Both may not be ideal, but active engagement can be more stimulating and disruptive to sleep
- Software like Flux can help reduce blue light exposure from screens
Contact Lenses and Eye Health
- Avoid sleeping in contact lenses to prevent infections
- Extended wear contact lenses not recommended by eye surgeons
- Daily disposable lenses are preferable if affordable
- Importance of eye protection and sunglasses
Cataract Surgery
- Not as daunting as it used to be
- Intraocular lenses have improved outcomes
- Can potentially correct other age-related visual changes
- Cataract surgery is typically a one-time procedure
Laser Eye Surgery
- Stability of prescription is important
- Length of the eye should be fixed
- Cornea shape is fixed during surgery
- Prescription should not worsen with age unless cataract formation occurs
Eye Health as an Indicator of Metabolic Health
- Eye is a transparent organ, allowing direct observation of issues
- Diabetic retinopathy can be an early sign of diabetes
- Microvascular disease in the eye can indicate issues in other organs (e.g., kidneys, toes)
- Using eye health as a standard for metabolic health could provide a more accurate understanding of a person’s overall health
- Not a binary diagnosis, but rather a spectrum of health
Glucose Migration and Lens Distortion
- Not a binary diagnosis, but rather a spectrum of health
- Glucose migration into the lens can be an early indicator of metabolic issues
- Lens distortion due to osmotic effect of glucose can be a canary in the coal mine for initial diagnosis and screening
- Technology to measure glucose in the lens is being studied, not commercially available yet
- Retinal vasculature can be imaged non-invasively with optical coherence tomography
- Diabetic patients with well-controlled sugar levels may still show signs of microvascular damage in their retina
Ophthalmology and Medicine Integration
- Ophthalmology should be more integrated into medicine
- Ophthalmologists can directly observe the brain and vascular tree, which can be helpful for systemic health
- More collaboration between ophthalmologists and other medical professionals can lead to better patient care and understanding of systemic health issues
Support the Podcast
Weekly Newsletter
- Weekly emails on the latest strategies and tactics for increasing your lifespan, healthspan, and well-being
- peterattiamd.com/newsletter
Peter Attia Membership
- peterattiamd.com/subscribe
- Member’s only Ask-Me-Anything Podcasts
- The Qualys, Members-Only podcasts
- Exclusive discount codes for products Attia believes in
Peter Attia Social Media